The Initiative for a Staged Accession to the EU

From the origin story…

While the European Policy Centre (CEP-Belgrade) published its first proposal on gradual integration back in 2018, it introduced a more structured approach in 2021 in the form of the ‘Template for Staged Accession to the EU’. Developed in cooperation with the Centre for European Policy Studies (CEPS-Brussels), it outlined a four-stage process with the aim of moving beyond the binary approach to enlargement and addressing the then-apparent impasse in accession prospects.

Its unique value lay in the fact it addressed the concerns of both candidate countries and member states while building upon the 2020 revised enlargement methodology. On the one hand, it entailed linking access to increased institutional and financial benefits to the level of reforms achieved during the pre-accession period. By doing so in a gradual, merit-based, and reversible manner, the proposal was intended to increase the predictability and credibility of the entire process, thereby unlocking the political will of candidate countries for essential reforms. On the other hand, it addressed concerns about the difficulties of decision-making in an enlarged but unreformed Union by introducing temporary institutional limitations and enhanced post-accession monitoring for new member states. This was intended to ensure that enlargement can proceed even if the EU’s internal reforms remain unfinished by the time a candidate country fulfils accession requirements.

Through these arrangements, the Model demonstrated that it is possible to pursue simultaneous deepening and widening of the Union without conditioning the latter on the former.

… to the updated Template 2.0

While initially met with caution, the Model’s relevance sharply increased just a year after its inception, when the June 2022 European Council endorsed the idea of “gradual integration” as the official approach to enlargement. Against this backdrop, CEP and CEPS published in 2023 the ‘Template 2.0 for Staged Accession’.

Template 2.0 emerged from wide-ranging consultations with officials from EU institutions and member states, as well as a series of publications that delved into the specific elements of the original proposal. The purpose of the revised approach was to provide a more detailed roadmap for the Model’s operationalisation in practice and make the most of the newly ignited enlargement momentum.  In particular, it outlined a step-by-step pathway towards maximising the potential of gradual institutional and financial incentives, while  also describing how post-accession veto limitations, including safeguard clauses, could be implemented in line with the EU’s legal order.

Most notably, it influenced the development of the European Commission’s New Growth Plan for the Western Balkans (NGP). Subsequently, the Model was referenced and supported in the European Economic and Social Committee’s (EESC) External Relations Section’s 2024 Opinion on the NGP. Soon after, CEP had the privilege of being invited by the Council Working Party on the Western Balkans Region (COWEB) to present Template 2.0 in detail and exchange views on the matter with member states.

Looking ahead, the Model is well-positioned to serve as a blueprint for the EU’s enlargement preparations, particularly in the context of ongoing discussions on safeguard clauses and other temporary post-accession limitations for newcomers.

Consists of

4

stages

Further operationalised in

37

CEP  publications

Directly advocated for in

 25

member state capitals

Referenced by

264

civil society papers

Publications on the Staged Accession Model

Template 2.0 for Staged Accession to the EU
A Quid Pro Quo Approach to Enlargement Reform: Streamlining Accession while Safeguarding the Union
Towards a New Generation of Safeguard Clauses: Making Conditionality Stick after Accession
The EU’s Comitology: An Opportunity for Early Institutional Integration of the Western Balkans
As POLITICO Reports: Our Veto-limitation Proposal Gains Traction
Impact of Western Balkan Accession on the European Parliament: Projecting Seat Allocation and Power Dynamics
A Step-by-Step Guide for the EU Council: Putting Gradual Institutional Participation into Practice
Moldova’s Road to EU Membership – Applying Gradual Integration
Reining in the Enlargement Vetoes: The German-Slovenian Non-Paper Under Review
From Bystanders to Contributors: A Realistic Way Towards Candidates’ Participation in the EU Council
The Role of Civil Society in Re-shaping EU Enlargement Policy in the Context of Geopolitical Changes: The Model for Staged Accession to the EU as a Case Study
EU Funds and Reforms: How Gradual Integration Is Changing the Rules of the Game
The New Growth Plan: Assessing the Value of the Proposed Early Integration Incentives
The Great Gap: Assessing the New Growth Plan’s Potential to Address Socioeconomic Disparity
Setting the Stage for Enlargement: The Integration of the Model for Staged Accession to the EU into the New Growth Plan for the Western Balkans
On financial and economic implications of the Staged accession model on the EU budget, and on acceding countries’ budgets
Sectoral integration opportunities in the SAA regime: The case for the internal market treatment of products
Reforming the EU’s pre-accession funding instrument: Effective membership preparation through the Staged Accession Model
The legality of a temporal suspension of veto rights for new EU Member States
Enabling gradual access to EU institutions with the Staged accession model
EU enlargement and the resolution of bilateral disputes in the Western Balkans
Unlocking the Regional Initiatives’Full Potential with the Staged Accession Model to the EU
Playing the Author: A Think Tank’s Hypothetical European Council’s Conclusions on Enlargement
Sectoral policy integration in advance of accession
Potential Application of the EU’s Staged Accession Model in Kosovo
Staged Accession Model – a Way to End the Stagnation of Bosnia and Herzegovina?
The Staged accession model in practice: Identifying the key challenges in front of Serbia
Dealing with “enlargement fatigue” to avoid “patience fatigue” in Albania
Potential application of the Staged accession model in the case of Montenegro
The Staged accession model in practice – Addressing the challenges ahead for North Macedonia?
Away with the enlargement bogeyman
The Enlargement Impasse and the Necessity for its Transformation
A Template for Staged Accession to the EU
The Model of Staged Accession: Addressing the EU’s four key concerns
The Model of staged accession to the EU: Addressing the Western Balkans’ three key concerns
Staged Accession Model as a proposal for operationalisation of the revised enlargement methodology

Further development of the staged accession model is also supported by the Open Society Foundations (OSF). Currently, CEP and CEPS are implementing a project called “Support for further development of the model of the Western Balkans staged accession to the European Union“. The essence of the Project is to focus on operationalising the Model. Issue papers, as well as Template 2.0 are developed under the scope of this Project.

The operationalisation of the Staged Accession Model has been supported by the Open Society Foundations Western Balkans (OSFWB). It included projects such as:

2024/25

“All in on EU Enlargement – Making Gradual Integration Work“

2023/24

“Building a Consensus on the Initiative for Staged Accession to the EU”

2022/23

„Support for further development of the model of the Western Balkans staged accession to the EU“

 

Stay tuned for updates on the staged accession by subscribing to our special newsletter edition!